Skip to main content

Full text of "The murder of missionaries in Rhodesia."

See other formats


THE MURDER OF 
MISSIONARIES 
IN RHODESIA 




THE MURDER OF MISSIONARIES IN 

RHODESIA 

The earliest permanent white residents of Rhodesia were missionaries, and it is 
significant that their lives were respected by the most warlike of the country's tribes. In 
an era of generally unbridled savagery, the innate chivalry of primitive warriors and the 
strict discipline imposed by their leaders seem to have been all that ensured the survival 
of the devoted little bands of men and women. 

Certainly it would be false to suppose that Christian conversion of the indigenous peoples 
contributed to the security of historical missionary outposts. Where the greatest danger 
may have seemed to lie among the regimented Matabele conversions were pitifully small. 

The conclusion that discipline and rudimentary soldiering qualities did much to preserve 
the lives of early missionaries seems inescapable. 

In the mid-1 970s intensification of the terrorist war in Rhodesia led to the increasing 
vulnerability of missions and their occupants. From religious convictions many staff 
members continued to go unarmed, and their quarters, clinics, hospitals and schools 
remained unprotected at their request. 

In contrast, other civilians trying to pursue their normal activities in similar areas turned 
to the offensive or formidably defensive. 

By 1976, numbers of missionaries, often acting against official advice, had become 
dangerously vulnerable. Although it had taken time for the undisciplined terrorist bands 
to appreciate this exposure of soft targets, it was inevitable that mission establishments 
and their members would prove irresistible prey for well-armed cowards. 

There appears to have been no logic behind the attacks which followed apart from that of 
the terrorists' overweening concern for their own safety. Often incapable of the resolve to 
assault defended buildings or even armed individuals, attention was turned to the 
undefended and the unarmed. It is doubtful if the basic political indoctrination to which 
the communist terrorists had been subjected could be held responsible for many of the 
attacks, despite the anti religious content of that teaching. 

Before any missionaries were killed in Rhodesia there were isolated instances of 
individual terrorist leaders demonstrating anti- religious views. A piece of rhetoric, left at 
the scene of an unsuccessful bridge demolition near a mission, closed with the words 
"Down with Christ." 

Subsequent to the first killings, in May 1977, a terrorist leader told missionaries: "If the 
Jews had not killed Christ, I would have done it myself." 



Other missionaries were told by terrorists not to mention Christ and His resurrection in 
the course of preaching. It has been pointed out that this restriction is ominously akin to 
similar impositions made upon the Russian churches. In another incident, the Roman 
Catholic Church was described as representing the evils of capitalism. 

In other instances, raids upon missions may have been provoked by those particular 
establishments failing to give what the terrorists considered adequate assistance. 

It is well known that some missions have helped terrorists, the motive sometimes being, 
presumably, a belief in the moral right of terrorists - more often a belief that assistance 
will result in the mission being left undisturbed and the staff permitted to continue their 
work after a black government comes to power. 

In the main however, the professionally meek and gentle were seen by the terrorists to be 
unprotected. Therefore, they were safe to murder, rape and expose to brutality of the most 
vicious kind imaginable. 

The deliberate selection of white missionaries may sometimes have had its origins in a 
wishful attempt to intimidate other whites. But the availability of defenceless victims in 
remote areas was clearly the most attractive facet. 

Missionaries have been murdered not so much for their faith - but because they were easy 
to murder. Their deaths are a tragic commentary on the arrant cowardice of "freedom 
fighters" and the inept leadership of those utterly undisciplined terrorists. 

FATHER JEORGER 

Father George Jeorger (42) from Switzerland, belonged to the Roman Catholic Order of 
Bethlehem, and worked at Bondolfi Mission in the Fort Victoria area. 

On November 25, 1976, he left his mission and drove to Mashati Township in the 
Mshawasha Purchase Area. Here - worried about the risk from landmines laid by 
terrorists - he set off on a bicycle to visit villages and smaller missions in the region. 

He was due to have preached at a local church on December 5, but did not appear. The 
authorities were told and investigations disclosed rumours that he had been murdered by 
terrorists. 

No trace has been found of Father Jeorger, whose name was incorrectly spelled "Oreger" 
in early reports. 

On December 22, 1976, a young terrorist was captured by security forces in the Nyajena 
Tribal Trust Land, which adjoins the purchase area in which Father Jeorger had vanished. 

During his trial in September, 1977, the terrorist claimed he had overheard a terrorist 
leader named Taurai say the priest had been murdered. 



Documents recovered at the scene of the young terrorist's surrender indicated that Father 
Jeorger had been abducted by a terrorist gang and tried by a kangaroo court. 

Despite the fact that the priest was well liked in the area, the documents listed various 
unsubstantiated "crimes" he was supposed to have committed. These were headed in the 
documents as "Accounts". 

A terse note at the end of the "Accounts" stated: "All these accounts and many others 
make him liable for a death penalty." 

There are certain parallels between the case of Father Jeorger and Father Desmond Paul 
Donavan, a 50-year-old Jesuit who was abducted near Salisbury on January 15, 1978. 
While the motor cycle he was riding was later found buried, no further trace of Father 
Desmond has been discovered. 

BISHOP SCHMITT AND HIS COMPANIONS 

On December 5, 1976, a terrorist ambushed and killed the 71 -year-old former Roman 
Catholic Bishop of Bulawayo, the Rt. Rev. Adolf Schmitt. Also killed in the same 
incident was a priest. Father Possenti Weggarten, and a nun. Sister Maria Francis van den 
Berg. The murders took place on a lonely dirt road near Lupane. 

First reports of the incident were summed up in a national newspaper next day: 

The only survivor of the ambush was Sister Ermenfried Knauer, who was 
brought fo Bulawayo last night and is recovering at the Mater Dei 
Hospital. 

She was shot in the left leg as she sought shelter under the bishop's car. 

There was a stunned silence among worshippers at St. Mary's Cathedral 
during the 6 p.m. mass yesterday when news of the murders was 
announced from the pulpit by the parish priest. Father Elmar Mayr. 

Dr. Johanna Davis, medical superintendent of St. Luke's Mission Hospital, 
who led the Police to the scene of the murders, and later brought Sister 
Ermenfried to Bulawayo by ambulance, last night recounted Sister 
Ermenfried's eyewitness story. 

She said that the bishop's party were driving from their home mission, 
Regina Mundi, to St. Luke's Mission to visit a sick friend. 

On the road between Gwaai siding and the main Falls road a terrorist held 
them up and demanded money. 



According to Dr. Davis, Sister Ermenfried said: "We told him we had no 
money with us, that we were missionaries just out for the afternoon. 

"We said, 'If you really need money, come back with us to the mission and 
we will help you'." 

The terrorist replied that as we had no money he would have to shoot us. 
He began gunning us down, starting with the bishop. He riddled him with 
bullets. Then he mowed down the others." 

Sister Ermenfried said she presumed the terrorist thought she, too, was 
dead. He fired at her leg which was protruding from under the car. 

According to Sister Ermenfried, the terrorist was wearing a balaclava and 
camouflage uniform and carrying a machine-gun. 

The Catholic Bishop of Bulawayo, the Rt. Rev. Henry Karlen, who 
succeeded Bishop Schmitt, said: "It is unbelievable." 

He said he had told an African who was returning to the Geneva 
conference to give a message to Mr. Robert Mugabe and Mr. Joshua 
Nkomo. 

The message was: "Tell those two gentlemen what has happened and that I 
said, 'This is the reward for our work for Africans for working for them all 
our lives'." 

The murders coincided with the ill-fated Geneva conference, and a newspaper report 
outlines reaction: 

Charges and counter-charges over the murders overshadowed the work of 
the settlement conference in Geneva yesterday. 

Two nationalist organizations - the Patriotic Front alliance and Bishop 
Abel Muzorewa's ANC - blamed the Rhodesian Army's Selous Scouts for 
the killings, while the Government delegation said the terrorist action 
should be taken as a warning about the future, lana reports. 

Mr. Mark Partridge, Minister of Lands and Natural Resources, told 
reporters, when asked about the nationalist allegations: "If you believe 
that, you will believe anything." 

Mr. Robert Mugabe's Zimbabwe African National Union said in a 
statement last night that it was "preposterous for us to be accused of 
murdering civilians". 



The incident was clearly an embarrassment to the nationalist delegation at Geneva. A 
reporter summed-up by writing: 

Their vehement denial of terrorist involvement and the blame they have 
placed on Rhodesian security forces are being regarded with utter disbelief 
by most foreign journalists. 

The only survivor of the massacre, Sister Ermenfried Knauer, said later that she would be 
prepared to accept the offer of a Rhodesian farmer to fly her to Geneva - where she could 
give evidence of the attack to any interested parties. 

A Press report stated: 

The wounded nun, Sister Ermenfried Knauer said she was not in a fit 
condition to travel at the moment. She said there was no doubt in her mind 
that the attack was carried out by a terrorist. 

She dismissed black nationalist allegations made in Geneva that the 
atrocity was carried out by Rhodesian security forces. 

Interviewed in hospital the sister recounted the events of the terrorist 
attack. She said the terrorist twice shouted out the slogan "missionaries are 
enemies of the people" before he gunned down the missionaries. 

She said the terrorist was unable to look his victims in the eye as he was 
pulling the trigger and it was apparent that he had been taught anti- 
missionary slogans as part of his training. 

On December 10, 1976, it was announced in the Press that Sister Knauer would not be 
permitted to visit Geneva: 

Sister Ermenfriend Knauer, the nun who survived a terrorist attack in 
Lupane on Sunday, will not be going to Geneva after all because her 
Mother General will not give permission. 

And last night the farmer who made the offer to pay Sister Ermenfried's 
fare said he was very disappointed with the Mother General's decision, 
and asked if there was no higher authority that could reverse her order. 

"I want this nun to go to Geneva," he said, "I want her to confront the 
people there and tell them the truth about what happened to her." 

Mother Adelberta Reinhart, the Mother General of the Missionary Sisters 
of the Precious Blood, said yesterday: "We are not going to enter into 
politics. They have more to do at Geneva now than talk to Sister 
Ermenfried. I would not allow her to go." 



Asked why Sister Ermenfried had said in an RTV-RBC interview at Mater 
Dei Hospital on Wednesday that she would go to Geneva, the Mother 
General said: "I think she only meant she is ready to give an answer." 

The farmer said: "I would like to remind the Mother General of my 
favourite quotation, 'AH that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that 
good men do nothing'." 

ST. PAUL'S MASSACRE, MUSAMI 

During the night of February 7, 1977, seven white Roman Catholic missionaries were 
murdered by terrorists. They included four nuns. A newspaper report set out the story as 
follows : 

In what the sole survivor described as a senseless, insane and brutal act, 
nationalist guerrillas last night gunned down seven white Roman Catholic 
missionaries, including four nuns. 

Father Dunstan Myerscough, who is 65, said today that he had escaped by 
throwing himself to the ground as the guerrillas opened fire from five 
yards range. 

Father Myerscough said he was in no doubt that the killers were 
nationalist guerrillas, although they had uttered hardly a word before 
shooting the helpless missionaries. 

The Dominican nuns who died were Sister Joseph Wilkinson (58), from 
Lancashire, and three West Germans - Sister Epiphany Schneider (71) and 
Sister Ceslaus Stiegler (59), both from Bavaria, and Sister Magdela 
Lewandowski (42) from Kiel. 

The male Missionaries killed were Jesuits - Father Christoher Sheperd- 
Smith (33), a Briton born in East Africa, Father Martin Thomas (45), from 
London, and lay Brother John Conway (57), from Tralee, Ireland. 

A Jesuit spokesman said that Brother John, who had worked for the 
Church in Rhodesia for 23 years, had virtually built the mission "with his 
bare hands". 

Father Myerscough, who is British, said that when the guerrillas arrived at 
the mission they began rounding up the white staff. "They appeared to 
ignore the black staff and sisters," he said. 

The group of eight was taken a short distance from the mission block, 
where the guernllas then argued in the vernacular as to whom would do 



the shooting, he said. "Finally, three of them turned on us and raised their 
guns. When the shooting started the others ran away." 

We didn't know they were going to shoot us until the firing started. I threw 
myself on the ground. When the firing stopped I looked up and saw that 
the other seven were dead and that there was nothing I could do for them." 

Rhodesian forces are hunting the guerrillas, whom the authorities say 
belong to Mr. Robert Mugabe's Zimbabwe African National Union 
{ZANU). A police spokesman said the group was believed responsible for 
a series of incidents, including the murder of several black civilians. 

Police said today they had recovered more than 100 cartridge cases fired 
from Russian-made rifles and a machine-gun. 

FATHER DIAZ 

The battered, mutilated body of Father Jose Manuel Rubio Diaz was discovered near a 
mission station in south-eastern Rhodesia. Father Diaz, who was 58, was born in Spain, 
and had worked in Rhodesia for 28 years. 

ST. PAUL'S MISSION, LUPANE 

Drunken terrorists were responsible for the deaths of two white women missionaries on 
March 10, 1977. 

A summary of the murders appeared in the Guardian (London): 

Two white Roman Catholic missionaries, both women, were shot dead by 
black nationalist guerrillas yesterday at St. Paul's mission in the Lupane 
district of south-western Rhodesia. 

A group of eight guerrillas entered the mission, in remote bush country, 
yesterday afternoon, threatening the black staff and nurses and demanding 
money from Dr. Johanna Decker (59) and Sister Ann Ploner (53). German 
born Dr. Decker had been in Rhodesia for 28 years, and Sister Ploner, 
born in Austria, but a South African national, volunteered for missionary 
work in Rhodesia six months ago. 

The guerrillas found Dr. Decker and Sister Ploner in the mission 
dispensary, and demanded money. Dr. Decker gave them the contents of 
the cash box but they said it was not enough. She said she had more at her 
house and was apparently shot down on her way to collect it. Mission staff 
said about R$400 (about £400) had been stolen during the attack, in which 
the insurgents assaulted the black mission staff, threatened the nurses with 
rape, and ordered the 130 patients from their beds. 



Another nun, Sister Damiane Drechsler (43) escaped death by hiding. She 
said she was sewing when the guerrillas arrived and she saw Dr. Decker 
pass her window at gunpoint. A few seconds later she heard the rattle of 
automatic weapons, followed soon afterwards by another burst in which 
Sister Ploner died, her body being riddled with eight shots. 

Rhodesian forces are hunting the insurgents, who are believed to have 
mounted Saturday's attack against the nearby Regina Mundi mission in 
which an Austrian-born building contractor, Mr. Rudi Kogler, was killed 
after he had shot dead an insurgent leader. 

According to St. Paul's mission staff, the guerrillas spent several hours at a 
nearby beer-hall before entering the mission, which is surrounded by a 
security fence. 

Another report, filed by A. J. Mcllroy, was published in the Daily Telegraph (London): 

I drove into the bush in a five-vehicle armed convoy to see at first hand 
the devastation, the heartbreak and the reality of the latest atrocity, this 
time in an area where Mr. Nkomo's ZAPU are operating. 

Mr. Nkomo, and Mr. Mugabe of ZANU, have been making terrorist 
attacks against civilian targets, and the latest victims yesterday were Dr. 
Johanna Maria Decker, 59, of Munich, killed by a single shot, in St. Paul's 
mission, near Lupane, on the Bulawayo-Wankie road; and Sister 
Ferinanda Ploner, 53, an Austrian. 

Sister Ploner's body was riddled by eight shots fired in a burst by the 
terrorists soon after they had shot down Dr. Decker. 

The two were among five whites at the mission, including the father and a 
monk in charge of a staff of 42 Africans looking after 130 black patients at 
the mission hospital. 

Forty of the women patients were in the maternity wards and among those 
who fled included women in labour who had their babies within hours in 
the bush. 

In a matter of 30 minutes a thriving hospital and a mission, including 
children nearby, was turned into a deserted compound behind the wire 
security fencing, leaving behind only three children, one a premature baby 
and the others in a ward where there had been a number of mentally 
retarded African children. 

There was only one gun at the mission. It was used by the father to 
slaughter pigs and cows for food. So unprepared were they and so sure of 



the love and affection which the local community had shown for them, 
and particularly Dr. Decker, that none of the staff even knew, or could 
remember, where the gun was kept. 

The atrocity by what were known to be a party of at least six black African 
terrorists bring the number of Roman Catholic missionaries killed in the 
last nine months to 13. 

Sister Ploner was serving with the Order of the Precious Blood and last 
night the Order was deciding what to do about the mission; whether to try 
to reopen it or find some other way of helping the local community. 

Clutching a key and padlock in her hand, after opening a security gate to 
the main building in the mission complex, Sister Damiane Drechsler, 43, 
from Heidelberg, who has been six years at the mission and came to 
Rhodesia in 1959, told visiting correspondents the sequence of events. 

She said that while she had been sewing she saw two of the terrorists 
leading Dr. Decker at gunpoint just outside the window of her room. 

Shortly afterwards she heard a "shattering" noise which she realized later 
was the shot which killed the doctor at a tree where she had been taken. 

Shortly afterwards, a further 200 yards away, there was a burst of shooting 
and Sister Ploner had been murdered. 

At one stage they found an African nurse who was leaving the linen closet 
in the main hosptal building and after saying "What are you doing here?" 
they pushed her on the floor and slapped her. 

Asked about Dr. Decker, she said: "She was the kindest person we have 
ever known. She has worked all over this area and had many remote 
missions who will miss her. She was devoted to the cause and had never 
hesitated to sacrifice herself in her work for the Africans, who in turn had 
grown to love her. 

"It was when they saw that she of all people had been shot dead by these 
men that they ran in panic and some didn't even stop to collect their 
babies." 

THE REV. AND MRS. BRAND 

On October, 23, 1977, the Reverend Andries Louw Brand (40) and his wife Tabina Metje 
Brand (41) were killed in a terrorist ambush. They were murdered while returning to their 
home in Que Que, after celebrating communion in the Gokwe area. Mr. Brand belonged 
to the clergy of the Dutch Reformed Church. 



They left six children. 

BROTHERS GEYERMANN AND VON ARX 

The next murder of missionaries by terrorists took place on the night of June 2, 1978. 
Two Catholic Brothers, German-born Pieter Geyermann and Swiss-born Andrew von 
Arx - aged 36 and 45 respectively - were killed by gunfire at the Embakwe mission 
school, close to the Botswana border. 

"It was definitely a terrorist attack," Father Angelmar Dylong of the mission was quoted 
as saying. The father was wounded in the same murderous assault. 

The attack had the effect of closing the school, which had served 250 students. 

SALVATION ARMY KILLINGS 

Five days later, on June 7, 1978, terrorists raided the Salvation Army Usher Institute. 
Christopher Munnion reported for the Daily Telegraph: 

Two British women mission teachers were shot dead and two other 
missionaries wounded in a cold-blooded raid by Rhodesian guerrillas on a 
Salvation Army institute near Figtree, 20 miles south-west of Bulawayo, it 
was disclosed yesterday. 

The two women who died were Miss Charon Faith Swindells, 25, from 
Bangor, Co. Down, and Miss Diane Barbara Thompson, 28, from 
Newcastle-upon-Tyne, whose parents live in Goldhawk Road, Shepherd's 
Bush. 

They were killed instantly when a 15-strong gang of guerrillas, members 
of Mr. Joshua Nkomo's Zimbabwe People's Revolutionary Army opened 
fire indiscriminately on a group of missionares. Injured in the shooting 
were Miss Gunvor Berit Polsson, 37, from Malmo, Sweden, and Mr. 
David Cotton, 38, from Atherstone, Warwickshire, whose family lives at 
Hadleigh, Essex. 

The guerrillas arrived at the Salvation Army's Usher Institute, a sprawling 
mission, on Wednesday night. 

Col. Ken Ramsey of the Salvation Army said the guerrillas sought out 
mission staff house by house and started to march six of them towards the 
house of the principal, Maj. Jean Caldwell, a Londoner. 

"They never got to the principal's house. The guerrillas must have been 
disturbed by something for they suddenly started to scatter into the bush". 
Col. Ramsay said. 



"Before they did so, they opened fire indiscriminately and hit four of the 
captives." 

Col. Ramsay said Mr. Cotton had been shot in the legs and Miss Polsson, 
the school vice-principal, was shot in the back. Their condition last night 
was said to be satisfactory. 

The teachers' deaths brought to 20 the number of missionaries killed in 
Rhodesia's 5 1/2-year-old war. 

The Usher Institute is close to the border with Botswana and 30 miles 
from the Roman Catholic Embakwe mission where two priests, one from 
West Germany, the other from Switzerland, were shot dead by guerrillas 
last Friday. 

According to police, the weapons used in the latest mission killings were 
assault rifles of the type supplied to Mr. Nkomo's army by the Soviet 
Union. 

MR. ARCHIE G. DUNAWAY 

On June 15, at Sanyati Mission, terrorists murdered a Southern Baptist evangelist - Mr. 
Archie G. Dunaway (58). 

Mr. Dunaway was married, with four children, and came from the United States of 
America. 

THE ELIM MISSION MASSACRE 

On the night of June 23, 1978, Elim Mission in the Rhodesian Eastern Highlands was 
subjected to the worst massacre of missionaries yet experienced. Terry Blocksidge 
reported in the Sunday Mail (Salisbury): 

Eight British missionaries and four young children - including a three- 
week-old baby - were bayoneted to death by terrorists on Rhodesia's 
Eastern border on Friday night in the worst massacre of whites since the 
six-year-old war began. 




Anng <nil3tr«lchcii (cwardai ihk aaoltm, Hurt^weefc^old hmela Crx* Abd hcf nHrthor, Mn. 
Jayce Grace, lie lidr by tide, tlkvaBtly baRcr«4 to dealh ao the pUylq field at E]lu MiHion. 

Three of the missionaries were men and the others women. 

A sixth woman was stabbed and beaten and left for dead. She staggered 
300 m into the freezing Vumba bush to spend the night before being found 
semi-conscious by security forces yesterday. Despite intensive care in a 
Salisbury hospital she subsequently died. 

The gruesome murders, by a group of eight to 10 terrorists, happened at 
Emmanuel Mission School - 15 km south-east of Umtali and 8 km from 
the Mozambique border - once used as the Eagle boarding school. 

The dead, who belonged to the Elim Pentecostal Church, were: 

* Mr. Peter McCann (30), his wife, Sandra (also 30), son Phillip (six) and 
daughter Joy (five). 

* The Rev. Phillip Evans (29), his wife, Suzan (35), and their daughter 
Rebecca (four). 

* Mr. Roy Lynn (37), his wife, Joyce (36), and their daughter Pamela 
Grace. She would have been three weeks old yester- day. 



Catherine Picken (55) and Elizabeth Wendy Hamilton- White (37). 



* Miss Mary Fisher (28). 

Most of the women had been sexually assaulted, and one mutilated. 

The children had been dragged from their beds. Two children were in 
yellow pyjamas, one with a red dressing gown, and a third in a flowery 
nightdress. 

One child had her tiny thumbs clenched in her palms. 

Even hardened security men were stunned by the bloody scene and stood 
around silently. "The quiet is uncanny", said one. 

Mr. Brian Chapman, director of the Church in Rhodesia and South Africa, 
visited the scene yesterday. He said: "We saw no humanity here." 

The massacre began shortly before 8.30 p.m. when the white families were 
forced by the terrorists from their homes and classrooms, and marched to a 
playing field. 

Near the sports pavilion, about 400 m from the main school, they were 
split into groups, then beaten with lengths of wood and logs, and stabbed. 

When security forces reached the scene yesterday, the full horror on the 
cold, mist-and-rain shrouded Vumba mountainside confronted them: 

A mother, beaten to death, lay with her young baby. The baby had also 
been savagely beaten. 

Their arms stretched out to each other, their hands resting an inch apart. 
The child's hand was clenched. 

The mother had a hand squeezed tightly around her engagement ring, 
turned into her palm, as she reached for her baby in her dying moments. 

Nearby, another woman had died from an axe-wound - the weapon still 
protruded from her shoulder - and two men, one with his hands tied behind 
his back, lay beaten and slashed to death. 

A blood-soaked chunk of wood had been dropped near to them. 

Three children lay in a pitiful huddle, with two women's bodies next to 
them. 

Some had raised their arms to defend themselves from the brutal blows. 



The reactions of the media in general were predictable, with many newspapers bein^ 
singularly outspoken. The Citizen of South Africa had this to say on June 26: 

Non-violence in many ways is being practised by the Patriotic Front. I 
asked one of their commanders, Tongogara, what they actually do in 
Rhodesia, and he said they're not doing much fighting, except when they 
are fired upon, or when the Rhodesian defence forces find them and try to 
run them out. 

"Basically what they are doing is moving around the villages and 
conducting political seminars and singing songs." 

So says Mr. Andrew Young, United States Ambassador to the United 
Nations, in a recent interview with the London Times. 

This weekend, in the worst atrocity committed against white civilians in 
the history of Rhodesia's six-year war, terrorists of Robert Mugabe's 
Zimbabwe National Liberation Army hacked and battered to death almost 
the entire white staff and their families at the Elim Pentacostal Mission in 
the Eastern border mountains. 

Mr. Young is asked: "Does Mr. Mugabe strike you as a violent man?" 

He replies: "Not at all, he's a very gentle man. In fact, one of the ironies of 
the whole struggle is that I can't imagine Joshua Nkomo, or Robert 
Mugabe, ever pulling the trigger on a gun to kill anyone. I doubt that they 
ever have.... The violent people are Smith's people and hopefully they 
won't be around for the new Zimbabwe." 

This weekend, when local and international journalists arrived at the scene 
of the massacre 15 km from Umtali and less than 7 km from the 
Mozambique border, the mutilated and blood-stained bodies of three men, 
four women and five children - including a three-week-old baby - were 
lying as they had been found that morning. 

Mr. Young is asked how he gets on with Mr. Mugabe. 

He replies: "I find that I am fascinated by his intelligence, by his 
dedication. The only thing that frustrates me about Robert Mugabe is that 
he is so damned incorruptible.... The problem is he was educated by the 
Jesuits, and when you get the combination of a Jesuit and a Marxist kind 
of philosophy merging in one person, you've got a hell of a guy to deal 
with." 

This weekend, one of the newspapermen who flew to the scene of the 
massacre reported: "The bodies lay in clusters round the school's cricket 



pavilion. The victims had all been foully abused. All but one of the four 
adult women had been raped and left semi-naked on the grass." 

Mr. Young tells of the "deep-seated humanism" of a young man who told 
him: "I started killing at 14 and when you kill and when you realize you 
could be killed for something that you believe in, you learn that there's 
nothing more precious and valuable than human life." 

This weekend, at the scene of the massacre, correspondents reported that 
the "victims were beyond help, with axe wounds scarring their bodies, 
bayonet thrusts deep in their backs, and skulls crushed by knobkerries or 
lengths of thick wood. 

Shocked and angry troops viewed the carnage and quietly cursed the 
terrorists. One man had tears in his eyes as he muttered: 'The bastards. 
They are nothing better than animals. How could they do this?' " 

Yet these are the terrorists whom men like Andy Young support. 

The tragedy of Africa is not just that such savagery still persists. 

It is that terrorism has been given respectability. That the men with the 
guns are regarded as freedom fighters, as liberators, when they are no 
more than thugs and animals. 

When will the World Council of Churches appreciate that it must stop 
aiding men who kill and maim the innocents? 

When will our local political priests accept that it is time to condemn, 
instead of support, such forces of evil? 

When will Mr. Andy Young and people like him realize that every man, 
woman or child who dies at Elim or at Kolwezi, or anywhere else on this 
dark continent, is a victim of insensate hate and barbarism? 

When will they back the forces of peace, of tolerance, of goodwill, instead 
of supporting the brutal and beastly terrorists? 

FATHER RICHERT AND BROTHER LISSON 

On June 29, 1978, the murder of two more Roman Catholic missionaries was described in 
the Rhodesian national press: 

Two German-born missionaries. Father Gregor Richert (48) and Brother 
Bernhard Lisson (68), who between them had served in Rhodesia for 
nearly 60 years, were shot in cold blood by a small group of terrorists near 



their quarters at St. Rupert's Mission, 60 km north-west of Hartley, on the 
afternoon of June 27, 1978. 

The murders were confirmed late yesterday afternoon by Combined 
Operations Headquarters, lana reports. The regional supervisor of the 
German Jesuits in the Sinoia area. Father Ulbrich, said in Sinoia that there 
was no apparent reason for the killings. 

"Was there a reason for the Vumba massacre?" he asked, referring to the 
murders last week of eight British missionaries and four of their children 
who were hacked and battered to death in the Eastern Highlands, reports 
lana. 

Father Ulbrich travelled to Sinoia from Salisbury yesterday to inquire into 
the deaths of his two colleagues. He said the two men were "extremely 
dedicated" to their work in the small, isolated mission and hospital 
complex not far from Sanyati, where they had made their homes for more 
than five years. 

Father Ulbrich said he believed three terrorists had committed the 
murders. He understood the small group of armed men had taken the two 
missionaries from the central mission complex to their quarters before 
shooting them. 

He said although terrorists were known to have an active presence in the 
area, he could think of no reason why St. Rupert's Mission had been 
singled out. "It's like so many other cases," he said. "It just seems to be 
indiscriminate." 

The Director of all Catholics in the Sinoia area, Monsignor Helmut 
Reckter, said his Jesuit organization had no plans to withdraw the 16 
missions left in operation. 

Asked why the murderers should have chosen helpless and dedicated 
missionaries as their target, Monsignor Reckter said: "It's extremely 
difficult to give an answer to this. I don't understand it. It is, of course, a 
very hateful business. There is no reason that makes sense to me." 

He said the 40-bed mission hospital, which catered for local tribesmen 
over a wide area, had already been closed. 

Reporting the murders in more detail, a communique from Combined 
Operations Headquarters said last night a sum of money was taken by the 
terrorists when they left in the late afternoon, and shots were fired into a 
mission vehicle. 



Three armed ZIPRA terrotists entered the mission and demanded to see 
the priest in charge. Father Richert was seen by them and went with the 
terrorists to Brother Lisson's quarters," the communique said. 

Both the victims were then forced to return to Father Richert's house, 
which they entered together with the terrorists. Their servant was told to 
leave. 

Shortly afterwards a single shot was heard, then three shots followed by a 
burst of automatic fire. 

RED CROSS TEAM 

The International Committee of the Red Cross, although it does not sponsor missionaries, 
is an organization respected and admired throughout the world for its humanitarian work. 
Its emblem - a red cross emblazoned on a white background - is universally recognized as 
a badge of neutrality, affording its delegates free and safe access to any war zone on 
missions of mercy. 

But this meant nothing to a Rhodesian terrorist gang. They ambushed the clearly-marked 
vehicle of a three-man Red Cross team as they drove along a rough mountain track in the 
remote eastern highlands of Rhodesia. 

The two ICR delegates in the vehicle, Mr. Andre Tieche and Mr. Alain Bieri - both in 
their early 30s and both from Switzerland - and their black translator, Mr. Charles 
Chatora, had no chance to escape the murderous fire. 

After the murders, the bodies were robbed of valuables, and even their shoes were taken. 
The pockets of their clothing were turned out to ensure nothing had been missed. 

The team were returning from a clinic after assessing the medical needs of local people. 
In the back of their truck was a bale of blankets for distribution to the needy. 

Red Cross members never carry arms. 

EVIDENCE 

Despite outraged protestations of innocence by the externally-based terrorist leaders - at 
Geneva and since - that their people were responsible for the murders, a wealth of 
unchallengeable evidence to the contrary has been amassed. 

The sworn evidence of missionary survivors has been backed by ballistic science and the 
written testimony of a well-known terrorist killed in a contact. 

Chief Inspector David Perkins, a ballistics expert with the British South Africa Police at 
the time of Musami Mission massacre of February 7, 1977, testified at the inquest that an 



AK rifle bearing the number 3036, of North Korean manufacture, had been proved under 
microscopic examination to be one of the weapons used in the slaying. 

A notebook found on the body of a terrorist, Mombi Macheni, contained the following 
passage: 

On Sunday the day of 6/2/77 we went to Musami at St Paul's Mission. We 
reached there at 9.15 and we had a storming raid. We shot four Europeans 
who were priests. Sisters were five, and altogether there were nine, eight 
dead. 

We took a watch only. No comrades were injured in the action. 

On the same day we went to Mazvidva and killed informers, kraalhead 
and the other one. This was 12.15, then we went. 

Nobody was injured. We were very happy. 

The entry in the notebook was signed by "No Talks" Mabhena. Beside his name was the 
number 3036. 

At the inquest. Father Myerscough was asked whether he had any doubt that the murders 
had been committed by terrorists He replied: "None whatever in my mind." 

The inquest verdict recorded by regional magistrate Mr Timothy Cherry: "Multiple, 
homicidal gunshot wounds" fired by a terrorist group. 

COUNTER CLAIMS 

Whenever the undisciplined terrorist groups commit some particularly brutal act, their 
leaders parrot the same response. 

Unable to control their gangs, frequently out-of-touch and seldom in any sort of real 
control, the leaders attempt to shift the responsibility to the Rhodesian security forces. 

But each victim of the terrorists is treated by the authorities as exactly what he or she - 
black or white - happens to be - a victim of murder. 

Repeatedly the world ignores the evidence. 

In the light of this asinine cold-shouldering of irrefutable fact, it is probably in vain to 
expect any logic to prevail. But what logical mind could accept that there has been a 
series of savage set-pieces, staged by Rhodesian forces? 

Already the world has adequate proof of the apathetic international reactions to horror in 
Rhodesia. Politicians, opinion formers and church bodies pay little more than lip-service 



to the conventions when forced to comment on some new atrocity perpetrated by the 
terrorists. 

Since the reaction is so peurile, would there be any rational purpose in stage-managing 
repeat performances - fraught with the danger of discovery or betrayal? 

Would any contrived "massacre" be worthwhile - in terms of cold cynicism - if all that 
could be expected was an assurance from Dr. David Owen that he would speak to Mr. 
Mugabe when next they met? 

Ministry of Information 

Rhodesia 

July, 1978 

Return to Main Page